HomePizzaMenuHistory and MissionMeet the OwnerContact

Stop by Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery in Reynoldsburg to try fresh baked bread, scones, pizza, and other treats.

It's the Holiday Season!

Let Tyler’s Pizzeria and Bakery
help you with your festive Holiday Season baking!

Pick up one of our checklist menus at the bakery, and drop it off later - or - peruse the menu below and give us a call to place you order!


We will be open for business the week of Christmas on Tues., Wed., and Sat. 9am-9pm.
Orders will be ready for pick-up on Tues. and Wed. (Dec. 22/23) by noon each day.

Holiday Specials!

Apple with crumb topping (10.95)
Pecan (11.95)
Pumpkin (10.95)

Dinner Rolls (half/dozen)
Sweet Rustic (2.50/5.00)
Italian (2.50/5.00)
Challah Knots (3.00/6.00)

Russenzopf - a deliciously sweet braided bread in a pan filled with cinnamon and pecans (6.95)

Stollen -  a sweet fruit and nut bread (7.95)

Every Day Favorites!

Sweet Rustic (5.00)
Italian (5.00)
Challah (6.00)

Cookies ($5 half dozen)
Iced Sugar Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal Cranberry
Iced Christmas Brownies (4-pak)

Quick Breads (5.95)

Scones (2.00 ea./11.00 half dozen)
Blackberry Pecan
Buttery Cranberry
Mixed Berry

Sweets (1.25 ea./6.50 half dozen)
Blueberry Chocolate Chip Bars
Cherry Cobbler Bars

Our pizza is baked in our wood burning stone oven. 

Our baked goods are made from scratch and baked fresh every day.

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery Mailing List
We invite you to join our mailing list to receive updates information throughout the year. Your information is safe with us and we will only use it to send you information about the Tylers Pizzeria and Bakery.

Email Address:
Verify image below:

Site Mailing List 
Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery - home of the wood fired oven!

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery
7516 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg, OH  43068 
Email: use contact form 

Site designed and managed by Assist By Evans.

Create your own website
WebStudio Website Builder